Showing posts with label marines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label marines. Show all posts

17 July 2009

BigDog -vs- Mules

My buddy Rhet sent me a link to a post on the Small Wars Journal about some transportation methods being developed for the US Military. Specifically, a robot named BigDog that can haul 380lbs over some very rough terrain. Check out the video below - it's pretty sweet looking.

HOWEVER (and it's a big however), the every thrifty and innovative Marines have figured out a way to haul heavy loads over rough terrain, using a very mature "technology" that doesn't require batteries, replacement parts or even gasoline. Yup, they use mules.

Which makes me wonder - if mules can effectively accomplish the mission, is the BigDog really necessary? Yes, BigDog is cool. I love it. I've watched this video several times and it gets me all excited. But the real question is, is it better?

Maybe it is. But frankly, that's likely to be a matter of opinion ("better" being a rather subjective word, don't you think?). And clearly, mules are the FISTy option.

Thoughts?